Wednesday, June 23, 2010


My mom gave me a bunch of tomatoes....a bunch. We have eaten tomatoes every day since then. Salads, sandwiches, sliced on the name it. But we're going away for my husband's neice's wedding and I knew they wouldn't last until we returned. What to do? (light bulb moment) Ah Ha! I'l make tomato pie!

Story time:
Back when I was over the Proverbs 31 Woman, FBC ministry I started what was called "Casserole Co-Op" at church. It was a blast! That first event, back in 2000 was a phenom! We had so many great dishes. The ladies would submit their recipe beforehand and the church compiled them into a booklet. The night of the "co-op" the ladies would bring their dish prepared and each lady would get a copy of the booklet. (be patient, I'm getting to the tomatoe pie story, I promise)

A friend, Lisa H, who was in my Sunday School class at the time brought a Tomato Pie. She said it was actually her friend's recipe, but in my mind it has always been "Lisa's Tomato Pie". Now, if you're turning up your nose right now at the thought of a tomato pie you can just stop that, right now. I thought the same thing when she mentioned bringing it to a Sunday School class party! I remember she called and said she was thinking about bringing a tomato pie. I'm thinking ... "really?", but I said "oh, okay". Lemme just tell you, everybody, and I mean men too, were going back for seconds! It was so delicious!!!
So when she said she was bringing that to the Casserole Co-Op, I knew it would be a hit. It was.

Now I own the recipe and have made it for several occasions to rave reviews myself! So, this is "whats for dinner" ! Hubby was very pleased to hear we were having Tomato Pie. I even got one of those "Wow! You haven't fixed that in a long time!" Oh, and you know that standing ovation I get when he's totally wowed with his meal? Yep. I got one!

So, by now you're probably saying "Enough! On with the tomato pie recipe!", right? Ok, then....

Tomato Pie

1 deep dish pie shell (I tried Walmart's generic brand instead of the "expensive" one I usually get, and it's really flaky! I like it!)
sweet basil
salt and pepper
1 chopped onion (recipe says small, but I never pay attention to that! LOL) Remember those onions I froze back in April???
1 cup cheddar cheese
1 cup mayonnaise (Now don't you go and hyperventilate over this. You're not going to eat the whole pie in one sitting, are you?)

Bake pie shell until almost done.

Slice tomatoes thickly. Completely cover the bottom of the pie shell.
Add salt and pepper.
Cover with onions, sprinkle basil.

Mix cheese and mayonnaise; spread ove pie.

Bake until hot and bubbly at 350 degrees. (approximately 20 minutes)

Notice the onions ON TOP??? I forgot the onions in the assembly so I put 'em on top because, like I said; I LIKE (cooked) ONIONS! and I wasn't going to leave 'em out.
Sorry there isn't a picture of them baked, we tore into 'em right away. Barely letting them cool!

** Note: Lisa says the only mayonnaise to use is Dukes brand (being the good South Carolina girl that she is) and it is good, but I had Hellman's and I really like that too so that's my Florida version of Dukes.


  1. Those tomatoes look tasty! what a fun recipe!

  2. I sampled this at the co-op and LOVED it!!! But never made it - now that I've been reminded I will!!!!

  3. This looks good but do you mind if I modify it into something with a bit more Italian flavor? I'll give you credit for the original and link back to your blog. Please let me know.

  4. I have never heard of a tomato pie before. It sounds really good.

  5. Oh how I LOVE Tomato Pie!
    I so so so need to make this!
    Thanks for reminding me how much I LOVE Tomato Pie!

  6. Amen on the Duke's mayo. I stay stocked in the stuff . I wish I could just jump in the screen & eat this !! I love tomato pie for sure :) If you still have that church booklet I'd love to see it - You know us church ladies love to cook a cassarole - I pretty much lived on 'em growing up . Just made my granny's squash cassarole this week . This will be next on the menu .

  7. sorry dear the comment above is from me ( southern mommas ) - Melissa @ sweet tea & biscuits

  8. You're making me covet my neighbor's tomatoes here...LOL. Mine won't be ready for another month but you can rest assured I'm going to try this recipe.

  9. Looks yummy. Is there much of a mayonaisey taste? I don't really care for the taste of mayo, but I eat several dishes with it as an ingredient.

  10. Jeanette, I made my Italian version of the pie today and it was a hit. I'll have a blog post up tomorrow with the recipe and some pictures. Be sure to drop by tomorrow. Thanks again for the inspiration!

  11. I've never heard of tomato pie before, I will try it though. I have a TON of tomatoes Thanks for the recipe :)

  12. Can I add potatoes - as a child in the UK ,was subjected to school "dinners" (ugh) except on a Monday, when Potato-tomato-cheeze pie was served - delicious...


I love your sweet comments and read them all. Please let me know you were here!


Related Posts with Thumbnails